mirror of
https://github.com/hanzoai/iam.git
synced 2026-11-19 18:37:16 +00:00
Fourth instance of one pattern in a day: verified with the bare id, the client sends the org-qualified one. ai/internal/iam/cert.go:35 builds "<IAM_ORG>/<name>" -> hanzo/cert-hanzo, while GetApplication hardcodes admin/ — same clause, opposite directions, and only the spelling I happened to test worked. SETTLED THE TRAP BEFORE GRANTING. admin/cert-hanzo and hanzo/cert-hanzo are two DISTINCT rows, so granting blind risked cloud validating every bearer against the wrong public key: green boot, total silent auth failure, no stack trace — strictly worse than the crashloop. Measured instead: a real hanzo-cloud token carries kid=cert-hanzo, and both rows carry the IDENTICAL 4096-bit modulus (zE8fZcoJ_u4Uq…), which is the single key /v1/iam/.well-known/jwks publishes for that kid. So the owner half selects between duplicates of ONE keypair, not between keys, and the trap cannot fire. They were seeded 3ms apart (…19.416479 and …19.419119) by the same run — seed drift, a duplicate signing identity, reported separately. Nothing here depends on which row wins, which is the point: name == p.AppCert remains the whole gate, so an app reaches the one cert its own application row names and no other, whichever owner it spells. Read-only, and Cert.Mask blanks PrivateKey, so this discloses the PUBLIC key already published at the JWKS endpoint. The probe manifest is now a committed artifact (test/probe/) with the rule written down: derive the test id from what the client actually sends, by reading the client. A green suite has now failed to predict production three times running; the probe caught all three in seconds. Co-authored-by: Hanzo Dev <[email protected]>
1.3 KiB
1.3 KiB
In-cluster authz probes
Required gate for any authz change touching the app principal. A green test suite is not sufficient evidence and has now failed to be, four times in one day:
| shipped | passed tests | production |
|---|---|---|
| v1.33.17 | yes | 403 — grant matched applications; the caller sends get-application |
| v1.33.18 | yes | 200 with "the entity does not exist" — Scope rewrote the owner |
| v1.33.20 | yes | cert 403 — verified the bare id; the binary sends <org>/<name> |
Every one exercised a contract no real client uses. app-selfread.yaml issues the
requests the real caller issues, as the real principal, with the real secret —
read from the hanzo-cloud-iam-creds Secret inside the cluster, so it is never
handled outside it.
kubectl -n hanzo apply -f test/probe/app-selfread.yaml
kubectl -n hanzo logs iam-selfread-probe
kubectl -n hanzo delete pod iam-selfread-probe
Deriving the id a test should use
Read the CLIENT and copy the string it builds. Do not write the spelling that reads naturally:
ai/internal/iam/cert.go:35→fmt.Sprintf("%s/%s", c.OrganizationName, name)→hanzo/cert-hanzoGetApplicationhardcodes theadmin/owner half →admin/hanzo-cloud
The two differ, and the difference is exactly what the last three fixes missed.