State migration reference

Why migrate

Context: Re-renders all consumers on any change; no granular subscriptions; becomes brittle at scale.
Redux: Heavy boilerplate (actions, reducers, selectors, Provider); slower onboarding; often used to mirror React Query or URL state.
Goal: Fewer mechanisms, domain isolation, granular subscriptions, single source of truth per state type.

React Query migration (server state)

Typical anti-pattern: API is called via React Query, then result is dispatched to Redux. Flow becomes: Component → useQueries → API → dispatch → Reducer → Redux state → useSelector.

Correct flow: Component → useQuery (or custom hook wrapping it) → same component reads from hook. No Redux/Context in between.

Prefer generated hooks from frontend/src/api/generated.
For “app state” that is just API data (versions, configs), one hook that returns { ...data, configs: useMemo(...) } is enough. No selectors needed for plain data; useMemo only where the value is used as dependency (e.g. in useState).
Set staleTime / refetchOnMount etc. so refetch behavior matches previous expectations.

nuqs migration (URL state)

Redux/Context often hold pagination, filters, time range, selected values that are shareable. Those belong in the URL.

Use nuqs for typed search params. Avoid ad-hoc useSearchParams + manual encoding.
Browser limits: Chrome ~2k chars practical; keep payload small; no large datasets or secrets in query params.
If the app uses TanStack Router, search params can be handled there; otherwise nuqs is the standard.

Zustand migration (client state)

One store per domain (e.g. DashboardStore, QueryBuilderStore). Multiple create() in one file is disallowed; use one store or composed slices.
Always use a selector: useStore(s => s.field) so only that field drives re-renders.
Never mutate: update only via set(state => ({ ... })) or setState / getState() + set.
State properties first, then actions. For 5–10+ top-level fields, split into slice factories and combine with one create().
Large client objects: Zustand is for “large” in the ~1.5–2MB range; above that, optimize at API/store design.
Testing: no Provider; stores are plain functions; easy to reset and mock.

What not to use

Redux / Context for new or migrated shared/global state.
Redux / Context to store or mirror React Query results.
Redux / Context for state that should live in the URL (use nuqs).
Zustand / Redux / Context for component-local UI (use useState/useReducer).

Summary table

State type	Use	Avoid
Server/API	React Query	Redux, Context
URL/shareable	nuqs	Redux, Context
Global client	Zustand	Redux, Context
Local UI	useState/useReducer	Zustand, Redux, Context

2.9 KiB Raw Permalink Blame History Unescape Escape