Files
Claude 07cf81bd47 Handoff layout: new README; build-chat notes moved to docs/build-notes/
- README.md: what this is, how to run and build it, the folder map, how light and dark
  mode work (@hanzo/appearance, @hanzo/design), where every price and checkout link
  lives, scripts, and known differences from live
- docs/build-notes/: status files, request notes, per-page checklists and reviews, plans
- Removed: screenshot galleries, captures of third-party sites used as references,
  the generated status page and its script, editor config, a personal working-rules file
- Code comments point at the new docs paths (no code changes)

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <[email protected]>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01P5YBdwj33XByFVTvu9bfci
2026-11-08 13:22:36 +00:00

8.8 KiB
Raw Permalink Blame History

/captable — James-eye review

Reviewed 2026-11-07 (late session), walked moving at 1470x801 and 375x812 (Playwright, wheel 400px every 700ms, rest pairs at 0.4/1.2/2.7/3.7s on the first screen and on screens 6 and 14, hover and press on every main control, both range inputs dragged, term sheet and a plan panel opened and closed with Esc). Proof: docs/build-notes/review/captable/desktop-first.jpg, desktop-walk.jpg, phone-first.jpg, phone-walk.jpg.

Verdict: 7.5/10 Ready: 8 Nov, copycheck missing 0 of 85 (hanzo.ai live), held up next to /api and /affiliate (James's new bar, no score). The hero Try Hanzo is the one solid fill (phones too), the ways rows' titles and links are real text runs (For Developers, Need a Custom Solution?, View on GitHub, Read the docs were invisible to the check as b/em), and the inline Captable, Inc. link answers hover. Usable: the round calculator, waterfall, term sheet and docs links. taste/unique OK; 0 console errors, no overflow at 1470 and 375.

First complaint: "I've just watched that table run in the hero, and the next section is the same table again, for six screens. And then there's a lot of white nothing between the bits. It's clever, but it reads like one spreadsheet shown twice, not one thing coming in as another goes out."

The 11 answers

  1. Sells in 5 seconds, moves within 1 second? Yes. h1 "Hanzo Cap Table" (52px), then a 112px "72.3%" founders figure, then the live table card. The round runs on its own: the pre-money moves $12M to $13M and the figure and table re-roll between 1.2s and 2.7s, with no input. A clear, product-first opener. But at rest on desktop there is no solid fill on screen: the header "Try Hanzo" is solid at 0.4s, then goes outline once the hero ask (also outline, data-thumb) is detected in view. The first screen ends up with two outlined "Try Hanzo" buttons and nothing filled (header ask bg measured rgba(0,0,0,0) at the top, rgb(10,10,10) after scrolling). On phone the header ask stays solid.
  2. One in, one out? Partly. The six chapters are a real pinned stage (01/06 to 06/06, one row lights up, the bar re-greys, a progress hairline runs). After that it is a document: term sheet card, black waterfall room, pricing, open source, close. On desktop the chapter scene opens with about 400px of empty right column between "The instruments, modelled" and "Share classes" (desktop-walk.jpg). On phone, the next chapter's text scrolls up under the pinned table half-faded ("classes, with authorized shares…" visible below the card), which reads as overlap for a beat (phone-walk.jpg).
  3. A real object in every section? Yes: hero table, pinned table, term sheet, waterfall with a draggable exit price, plan cards with panels, the fork drawing and repo card, the close row. The fork drawing reads thin at rest: a few grey dots and one short ink stroke inside a large grey tile.
  4. One ask, sticky after the hero? The header carries "Try Hanzo" sticky and solid after the hero. The close repeats it (outline) with a full-width "Get started with Cap Table / Read the docs" row. Nothing floats over content. Scale has rhythm: 112px figure in the hero settling smaller, 26px heads, 64px exit price that grows while dragged ($6.0M to $43M); one big thing per screen.
  5. Every hover and press answers? Almost all. The hero ask gets a border and ring and presses at scale .98. "Documentation" underline draws and its arrow steps 4px. Pause gets a fill and presses at .97, and it really holds the round (text unchanged over 3s). The term-sheet button, plan cards (#f2f2f2 to #ededed, Growth #171717 to #262626, press .97), the doc rows (fill #f2f2f2), the repo chip and the close row all fill. "Upstream" and "Deploy to Cloud" underline and step their arrow. The one miss is the inline "Captable, Inc." link, which has no measured hover change. The term sheet slides in from the right (x 1482 to 838) and Esc returns it. The plan panel opens centred and Esc closes it.
  6. Overlap, font swap, layout shift? No font swap seen; the h1 box is stable from 0.4s. CLS is 0.0002 on desktop and 0.019 on phone (source ct-pch-list, the phone chapter list, at about 9.3s): under the bar but close. No horizontal overflow at either size. A hydration badge appeared once at each size under shared load (desktop "Hydration failed", phone attribute mismatch); 3 solo reloads per size showed 0 errors and no badge, so it is not counted.
  7. Which reference, and is its motion there? apple.com product page: a pinned stage where one panel changes, product as hero. That motion is present and smooth. A motion.dev-style digit roll is on the figures (mid-roll the digits ghost and overlap; acceptable as a roll, a touch muddy when dragged fast). Nothing of osply/hamol: the asymmetry is there, but the dead space between parts undercuts it.
  8. Different from its neighbours? Yes in medium: the hero is a live figure plus a modelling table, not a phone or a rail. The pinned-table-plus-steps pattern is generic to the kit's chapters, though; the page's own idea (a round you can run) is strongest in the hero and the waterfall.
  9. All 18 parts covered? The card is filled for 18 of 18. Claims checked on the page: the self-running round (true), the 44px pause with aria-pressed (true), the figure settling on scroll (true), the phone pinned compact table (true), the exit price growing while dragged (true), the term-sheet and plan panels (true), no overflow (true). One claim is false at rest: "the header's 'Try Hanzo' is the one solid fill … 0 page-owned solid buttons in the first 1470×801 view". There are 0 solid buttons of any kind there once the header goes quiet, so the first desktop view has no filled ask.
  10. Banned tells? None hard. No hue, no gradient text, no kicker above the h1 ("Equity Management Platform" sits below it). The "MOST POPULAR" white pill on the Growth card is Hanzo's copy, set beside the label rather than above a headline. Pricing is 4 near-equal boxes in a staggered 2x2. That is not the banned three-in-a-row, but the cards are mostly empty (label at the top, about 200px of nothing, then the price).
  11. Copy untouched? It looks untouched. One note: "At an exit price, who gets paid and in what order." appears as chapter 06's text and again straight after as the waterfall h2, so the visitor reads it twice within one screen.

Fixes (ordered, most important first)

  • Stop showing the same table twice in a row. The hero card (4 rows: holder, class, shares, fully diluted) and the chapter card "A round, run first" are the same object about 400px apart. Either hand the hero table into the pinned stage (the hero card becomes the pinned card as you scroll, one object travelling), or give the chapters a different view of the round (for example the bar alone at full width, with one class lit per chapter). Today it reads as repetition, not progression.
  • Give the first desktop screen one solid ask. When the hero ask (data-cta="captable.hero", outline, 124x48 at y 662) is in view, the header ask drops to outline and nothing on the screen is filled. Make the hero "Try Hanzo" the solid fill while it is visible (MASTER part 4: "the solid fill sits in one place at a time: the hero ask, then the bar"), or stop marking it thumb so the header keeps its fill.
  • Close the dead space in the chapter scene and the open-source section. Desktop: the first chapter text ("Share classes") sits about 400px below the section heading with an empty right column above it. Bring step 01 up to align with the top of the pinned card (y about 160). Open source: the right column ends at "Contact Sales →" and leaves about 280px of white with a stray hairline under it. Align the columns' ends, or let the repo card and the link rows share one baseline.
  • Tighten the pricing sheet. The four plan cards (325x300 and 325x372, staggered) carry about 200px of empty fill between the mono label and the price, and the left column under "Simple, Transparent Pricing" is empty for about 600px. Shorten the cards to their content (about 180px, as on phone) and keep the staggered rhythm with smaller offsets, or put one real detail in each card's empty top (its first feature line from the panel, in Hanzo's words).
  • Phone chapters: hide the outgoing text under the pin. At 375 the previous chapter's paragraph shows half-faded directly under the pinned table ("classes, with authorized shares, par value and voting rights."). Clip it at the card's bottom edge, or fade it fully before it reaches the card. Also bring CLS from ct-pch-list (0.019) down by reserving its height.
  • Smaller: give the "Captable, Inc." inline link a hover answer (underline thickness or offset step, like the other links). Make the fork drawing read at rest (more of the branch drawn, or ink rather than grey). Avoid reading the chapter 06 sentence twice by letting the waterfall h2 take over as chapter 06 ends.