- README.md: what this is, how to run and build it, the folder map, how light and dark mode work (@hanzo/appearance, @hanzo/design), where every price and checkout link lives, scripts, and known differences from live - docs/build-notes/: status files, request notes, per-page checklists and reviews, plans - Removed: screenshot galleries, captures of third-party sites used as references, the generated status page and its script, editor config, a personal working-rules file - Code comments point at the new docs paths (no code changes) Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <[email protected]> Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01P5YBdwj33XByFVTvu9bfci
4.6 KiB
/comparison — James-eye review
Verdict: 8/10 Ready: 8 Nov, held at missing 0 under the real copy check (copycheck 0 of 27): each receipt line now shows the images its own compose file runs (live's image column), duty sentences whole; the closed images sheet no longer pushes the page 1052px sideways and reduced motion no longer breaks hydration (shared fixes). 0 console errors (also under reduced motion), no overflow at 1470 and 375. Usable: toggle stacks to price your own selection; Try Hanzo. First complaint: "The headline's small and off to the left with a big empty patch beside it, and the total, the whole point, is below the fold on my laptop."
Walked 7 Nov 15:16 (third walk, after the shared system landed), page file at 18823f5f (components/pages/Comparison.jsx, Comparison.css), unchanged during the walk. Judged by docs/JAMES.md and docs/build-notes/MASTER.md. Filmed moving at 1470×801 and 375×812 (wheel and finger scroll, dwell on every screen, hover and press on desktop, taps on phone), plus reduced motion and JS off. Stills: review/comparison/desktop-walk.jpg, review/comparison/phone-walk.jpg. The machine was overloaded, so motion is judged from frames.
What works
- The bill is the object. A paper slip feeds out of a black slot under the hero and prints its eleven stacks line by line.
- Every line is a switch. Take a stack out and the total rolls to the new figure ("Your selection 10 / 11, $221.19/mo"). The price list now shows once, not twice.
- Scale has rhythm: h1 at rest (52px), the total as the one big figure of its screen, and the dark room's "$ ?" at figure size.
- The dark room is still the best moment on the page. A tilted receipt lists the five things you hold (Upgrades, Backups, Availability, Identity, On-call). Each comes in beside its sentence as the last goes out, each priced "$ ?". Then Hanzo's closing line and the ask.
- Greys and ink only;
taste.pypasses. Nothing floats over content: the old total pill is gone. - One ask, "Try Hanzo": in the hero and again closing the dark room.
- The checks pass: parity 63/63; CLS 0; reduced motion 0 running animations; JS off shows all 24 text blocks; press scales to .97; the switches answer tap and hover.
The 11 answers
- Sells in 5 seconds, moves within 1 second? Yes on words, and the slip feeds once the page arrives. After the feed, the first screen is still until you touch it.
- One in, one out, or a document? Yes: the hero, the bill, then five duties one at a time.
- A real visual object in every section? Yes: the slip and the duty receipt.
- One ask, sticky after the hero? In the hero and the dark room. After the hero, the header and phone bar carry "Try Hanzo" (shared).
- Every hover and press answers, no jumps? Yes.
- Overlaps, font swap or layout shift? None. The "1 Issue" hydration badge is shared.
- Which reference, is its motion there? Apple's pinned chapter in the dark room, and osply's calm type. Both there.
- Different from neighbours? Yes. A printed bill and unpriced receipts are its own; nothing else in Proof uses paper.
- 18 parts (MASTER card)? 18 of 18
Done here:lines, checked below. - Banned tells? None. "COMPARISON" is a caption over the lede, not over a headline.
- Copy untouched? Yes. Every price and the method note (compute only, DigitalOcean retail plus Hanzo margin, estimate) are Hanzo's.
Card check (docs/build-notes/coverage/comparison.md)
- 18 of 18 filled.
- Spot-checked as true: part 3 (52px h1 on the 8/5 split, slip feeding within 1 s, JS off 0 hidden), part 6 (each price once), part 7 (the total as the one big moment), part 11 (no floating pill) and part 17 (empty selection shows $0.00/mo).
What is missing
- Part 3: the first screen has no big thing. The h1 is at rest size, the slip shows its title and three lines, and the total sits about 700px below the fold.
- Part 9: after the feed, nothing in the hero moves by itself.
Fixes
- Put the total on the first screen. Show the slip's foot ("All of them, running $225.57/mo") as soon as it feeds, pinned under the slot while the lines print above it. Or shorten the feed so the total lands above the fold at 1470×801. That is the one big thing for the hero.
- Close the empty patch. Bring the slip up beside the h1 on the 8/5 split (h1 and lede left, slip right, aligned to the bottom), so the first screen has one focal object, not a gap.
- Keep the slip alive at rest. For example, the line under the pointer lifts and shows its vCPU and GB, or the "11 / 11" counter ticks as lines finish printing, so the hero still answers after the feed.