Files
Claude 07cf81bd47 Handoff layout: new README; build-chat notes moved to docs/build-notes/
- README.md: what this is, how to run and build it, the folder map, how light and dark
  mode work (@hanzo/appearance, @hanzo/design), where every price and checkout link
  lives, scripts, and known differences from live
- docs/build-notes/: status files, request notes, per-page checklists and reviews, plans
- Removed: screenshot galleries, captures of third-party sites used as references,
  the generated status page and its script, editor config, a personal working-rules file
- Code comments point at the new docs paths (no code changes)

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5.5 <[email protected]>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01P5YBdwj33XByFVTvu9bfci
2026-11-08 13:22:36 +00:00

6.9 KiB

/dataroom — James-eye review

Ready: 2026-11-08 copycheck missing 0 of 84 (COPY-RULE): the close follows Hanzo's order as real headings and lines (Start Sharing + its line over the solid Try Hanzo; Documentation / For Developers / Need a Custom Solution? rows with View Docs, View on GitHub, Contact Sales; "Get started with Dataroom" with Read the docs and View on GitHub; a "Get Dataroom" card: Secure data room, License: AGPL-3.0, hanzoai/dataroom, 3 stars, Deploy to Cloud), so a visitor sees how to start sharing or deploy; repo cards name hanzoai/dataroom and Upstream: mfts/papermark as their own text; "Send the link" carries its line; Free and Business plans list every item Hanzo lists; Hanzo's Zen film (zen.webm over zen.webp) is back, in a dark band beside "A link, shared" (still under reduced motion). taste OK, unique OK, check.mjs 0 errors / 0 Next issues / no overflow / 0 overlaps at 1470 and 375; 0 issues in 5 loads incl. reduced motion. 7 Nov. Walked moving at 1470x801 and 375x812 (phone: isMobile, hasTouch) with Playwright on this worktree's dev server (:4182). At each size: frames at 0, 1 and 3 s with no input, then wheel scrolls of 0.85 of a screen with a 1.5 s dwell to the footer, hover and press on every control in main on desktop, taps on phone. Measured CLS, horizontal overflow and console output. Component: components/pages/apps/Dataroom.jsx.

Verdict: 7/10

First complaint: "The top half is lovely. The deck pages reading themselves, the dark bit where I flip the switches and get the gates. Then it's a pricing table, a paragraph about Papermark and a list of links, and it just goes flat. And on the first screen there's no proper button. 'Try Hanzo' is a thin outline, same as the one in the header."

The 11 answers

  1. Sells in 5 s, moves within 1 s: yes. "Hanzo Dataroom", "SECURE DOCUMENT SHARING" and the lede sit on the left. On the right the reading room for Deck.pdf runs by itself from first paint: the page strip scrolls with the reader, the current page's bar fills ("how far they got · 4/10" at 0 s, 6/10 at 3 s), and the feed says "page 6 reading now" / "verified email opened the link". There is a pause button. The weak spot is the "VIEWS 1" figure: it stayed at 1 for the whole 3 s, so the one big number on the screen is the one thing that doesn't move, with a large empty block beside it.
  2. One in, one out: yes for the first half, no after. Five sticky chapters (Add the documents, Send the link, Set who may open it, See what they read, Change your mind) change one product panel in place, and on phone each chapter carries its own panel. Then the file tree whose rows open into their page, and the dark "A link you still control" room. After that comes pricing as a four-plan ladder of bullet lists, "Built on Open Source" (a heading and a paragraph), a five-row link list and the closing "Upload one document and send the link". That second half is a document. On phone the page is about 13,200px tall.
  3. A real object in every section: until pricing. The reading room, the chapter panels, the file tree, the gate simulator and the close all hold real UI. The pricing ladder, the open-source section and the link list have no object, and at 1470 the open-source section is one paragraph in about 400px of white.
  4. One ask, nothing floating: the ask is not solid on the first screen. The hero "Try Hanzo" is an outline pill (hover raises it with a border and shadow), and the header's Try Hanzo is outlined at the top, so the first screen has no solid fill. The header turns solid once you scroll. The close repeats Try Hanzo. Nothing floats over content apart from shared chrome. Scale: the 52px h1, a 64px views figure, then 26px heads; the figure is the one big thing, but it does not change.
  5. Hover and press: mostly yes. The file rows tint on hover and press at scale(.99); the share switches press at scale(.98) and type your email into the gates; Verify takes a shadow. Weak spots: four of the six switches ("A verified email", "An NDA to accept", "Downloads off", "Watermark") show no hover change in their on state, and the text links (Documentation, Get on GitHub, Contact Sales, hanzoai/dataroom, Upstream) only nudge 1px on press, with no hover change on the link itself.
  6. Overlap, font swap, layout shift: clean. CLS 0.0005 on desktop and 0 on phone. No font swap; the h1 holds its box. No horizontal overflow. The reading room intentionally bleeds off the right edge at 1470. No overlaps.
  7. Reference: synchronized.studio (files open into their page) plus apple (sticky chapters). Both are present: the tree rows open into their page through BizOpen, and the chapter panel changes in place. The share-it-ten-ways room is closest to an Apple "try it" moment. There is no huge-type moment and no count-up, even though the views figure invites one.
  8. Different from its neighbours: yes. The live reading room and the gate simulator are specific to a data room, and the Biz* frame differs from the cloud Keynote pages.
  9. The 18 parts: card is 18/18 (docs/build-notes/coverage/dataroom.md, every Done here: filled). On the page: one h1, a pause control, switches with state, an email field, a closing band. Gaps: the feature descriptions in the file tree are cut with an ellipsis at 1470 ("A password, a verified email, an …"), and the ask has no solid on the first screen.
  10. Banned tells: none. Deck greys only, no Inter, no gradient. "SECURE DOCUMENT SHARING" sits below the h1, not above it. scripts/taste.py: OK.
  11. Copy: untouched. scripts/parity.py /dataroom: OK, text 102/102, links 8/8. Truncating the tree's descriptions with an ellipsis hides Hanzo's words on desktop.

Not counted: a red "1 Issue" hydration badge in walk contexts, clean on a fresh single load (shared finding 3). scripts/unique.py: no clash for /dataroom.

Fixes, in order

  1. Give the second half a stage. Turn pricing into one panel that changes between plans (Free, Pro, Business, Data Rooms) instead of four bullet lists, and give "Built on Open Source" an object: the hanzoai/dataroom → mfts/papermark relationship as a small repo card pair, not a paragraph. Fold the five-row link list into the close.
  2. Make the views figure tick. Let the 64px "VIEWS" count up as each visit arrives in the feed (1 → 2 → 3 on the reading room's own cycle), so the one big thing on the first screen is alive.
  3. One solid ask on the first screen. Make the hero Try Hanzo solid (or the header's while the hero is in view), so the first screen has exactly one solid fill.
  4. Don't truncate Hanzo's words in the file tree. Let the description wrap to two lines or show it on hover/open rather than an ellipsis at 1470.
  5. Hover on every switch and link. Give the on-state switches a hover (track darkens or thumb nudges) and the text links an underline draw or arrow nudge.
  6. Fill the empty block beside the views figure at 1470 (put the feed beside the figure at full height, or move the figure down next to the strip).