Files

6.9 KiB
Raw Permalink Blame History

/press: James-eye review (critic 3, 7 Nov)

Ready: 2026-11-07, slice D — unverified motion-map rebuild checked and finished: kit plates on one baseline, light plate visible, zip line unclipped, velocity-skew 8°→3°, stack-drop without bounce, magnet grid breathes 3 idle ripples; review fixes from ebf5c606 hold (phone pills clear, news walks, partners one row)

Verdict: 7/10 First complaint: "On my phone the little SVG, PNG, ICO pills are printed straight through the logo. That's the press kit, the one thing a journalist comes for, and it looks broken."

I walked it with Playwright at 1470×801 (wheel, desktop hover flags) and 375×812 (touch), cookie bar dismissed. I waited about 4 s on each section, then took three shots 1.2 s apart, and probed hover and press on 12 controls. Parity: /press: OK text 83/83 links 20/20. Layout-shift observer: 0 entries at both sizes. No horizontal overflow. The only console errors are 8 resource 404s: the 2 portraits and 6 partner logos that this sandbox blocks. Their fallbacks (initials on a Sigil plate, letter chips) look intended.

The 11 answers

  1. Sells in 5 s, moves within 1 s? Yes. The h1 "Press Resources." cuts in by mask, the lede and asks rise once, and a sheen crosses the dark kit plate untouched. A journalist knows right away: kit, contact, download. On desktop, about 200px under the hero is empty, so the next section does not peek.
  2. One in, one out, or a document? Half and half. The pinned hero, where the stack deals out into the three-plate spread as the headline leaves, is a real "one in, one out" moment. Past it, the page reads as a well-set document. Three of the six lower sections are hairline lists (news 6 rows, partners 6 rows, channels 9 rows). Before News and before Connect there are bands of about 350px of empty white with nothing in them.
  3. A real visual object per section? Mostly. Kit plates, the 2016 figure, the dark news card, the 52px email in the black room, the Brand Guidelines mark, the large walked handle, and the team plates. Partner Assets is a letter-chip list here, which is a fallback, so I did not count it against the page.
  4. One ask in the header, nothing floating, scale rhythm? Desktop: yes. "Contact Press Team" takes the header (quiet in the hero, solid once the hero ask leaves, white in the black room), and there is one solid fill per viewport. The closing "Request Executive Bios" is quiet. Scale has rhythm: one big thing per screen (h1, 2016, the email, the handle), with mono captions and medium titles around it. Phone: see the shared-chrome note.
  5. Every hover and press answers, no jumps? Yes. Asks darken, press scales to 0.97-0.98, and boxes did not move by a pixel. News rows underline, the arrow slides 6px and the side card swaps its number, summary and date. Social rows fill and the name shifts 8px. Partner downloads invert to ink. Copy buttons invert and tick. Plates scale 1.04 and their pills invert. The team plates are not controls and rightly have no hover.
  6. Overlap, font swap, layout shift? Overlap at 375×812 (img/press-phone-pills.jpg). On the "Logo - Light Background" and "Icon Only" plates, the format pills (.xpe-fmt, absolute top-right) sit on top of the mark: "PNG" is printed through the black icon and "SVG" touches the wordmark's mark. It is on the phone's second screen. No font swap and no layout shift seen. On desktop, the rear plates' pills peek past the front plate's edge in the hero stack (a stray "G" fragment), which is small but untidy.
  7. Which reference, is its motion there? It feels editorial, like osply/hamol: confident asymmetry, mono captions and a pinned stage (Apple). The pinned deal-out and the line-mask cut-ins are really there. What is missing is the "alive" part. After arrival, About, News, Contact and Brand Assets are pixel-still on desktop (0 changed pixels over 2.4 s each; img/press-desk-still.jpg). Every beat there (typing, hairlines, the 01→09 walk) runs once and stops. Between the hero sheen and the team Sigils, nothing moves unless you scroll or point.
  8. Different from neighbours? Yes. About opens tiles into sheets, Investors rolls figures, History scrubs a year and Brand shows a type specimen. A kit that deals out from a stack belongs to this page alone.
  9. 18 parts? Largely. Header comment, one h1, data-cta/data-thumb, JS-off styles, reduced-motion end states, sr-only "Copied" status, 44px targets and kit fallbacks are all there. The gaps are part 3 (no 56px peek under the desktop hero) and part 11 (the phone overlap above).
  10. Banned tells? None in the page. There is no hue, and the eyebrows ("Press & Media", "Leadership") sit below their headings as captions. No gradient text and no Inter. One thing to look at: at rest the boilerplate ends with "everyone." still grey, because the word fill finishes after the section has settled. It reads like a styling slip, not a reveal.
  11. Copy untouched? Yes: parity 83/83 text and 20/20 links.

Shared chrome (not counted against the page): at 375×812 the header shows a solid "Try Hanzo", not the page's "Contact Press Team". That puts two solid fills on the phone's first screen and the wrong ask in the sticky header. The glass header also smears a grey blur band over content in a few desktop frames. Both are for the header owner.

Fixes to reach 8

  1. Clear the phone overlap. Under 899px, take the format pills out of the plate's corner: set them in flow under the plate, or reserve top padding equal to the pill row so the mark centres below them. At 375 no pill may touch the mark on any of the three plates. Also clip or hide the rear plates' pills in the desktop hero stack so no fragment shows past the front plate.
  2. Give the middle something alive at rest. At least one ambient, non-scroll mover in About → Brand Assets, using a single continuous mover per viewport and existing content only. For example, the news card could keep walking the six stories slowly on desktop (pausing on pointer and focus, with a pause control) instead of holding 01. Or the black room could keep a slow sheen or Sigil drift behind the email. Right now four screens in a row sit dead after their one-time beat.
  3. Remove the dead white bands. The roughly 350px empty gaps before Recent News and before Connect With Us read as an unfinished document. Tighten those section paddings, or let the next section's object peek 56px into them. Do the same under the desktop hero, so the next thing peeks (part 3).
  4. Let the boilerplate finish. End the word fill (offset end) early enough that the whole paragraph, "everyone." included, is fully ink once the section is at rest in the viewport.
  5. Break up the list rhythm. News, partners and channels are three hairline lists in a row in the lower half. Without adding copy, give one of them a different form (for example, partners as one still logo row, as the page's own header comment promises) so the lower half stops reading as three lists one after another.