4.1 KiB
Jobs-To-Be-Done Framework - Detailed Methodology
The Milkshake Story
Clayton Christensen's famous example:
Surface Problem: McDonald's wanted to sell more milkshakes
Traditional Approach: Improve flavor, make thicker, add toppings
JTBD Approach: What "job" are people hiring the milkshake for?
Discovery:
- Morning buyers: "I need something to make my commute less boring and keep me full until lunch"
- Afternoon buyers: "I want to bond with my kid and feel like a good parent"
Insight: SAME product, DIFFERENT jobs, DIFFERENT competition
Morning milkshake competes with: bagels, bananas, boredom Afternoon milkshake competes with: ice cream, toy stores, playground
The Job Statement Formula
Basic Structure
"When [situation/trigger], I want to [motivation], so I can [expected outcome]"
Examples
TeddySnaps Parent: "When I'm at work and missing my child, I want to see they're happy and engaged, so I can feel like a good parent even though I'm away"
TISA Parent: "When I'm choosing a school, I want my child to develop real-world skills, so I can feel confident they'll succeed in life"
GolfTab Golfer: "When I'm hungry on the course, I want food delivered without disrupting my game, so I can keep enjoying golf without hangry frustration"
Forces of Progress
Four forces determine whether someone "switches" to your solution:
Push of Current Situation
What's wrong with how they do it now?
- Pain points
- Frustrations
- Unmet needs
Pull of New Solution
What's attractive about the alternative?
- Better outcomes
- New capabilities
- Emotional benefits
Anxiety of New Solution
What fears prevent switching?
- Will it work?
- What if I lose X?
- Is it complicated?
Habit of Current Situation
What makes staying comfortable?
- Familiarity
- Sunk costs
- "Good enough"
Switch happens when: Push + Pull > Anxiety + Habit
Job Hierarchy
Core Job
The fundamental thing they're trying to accomplish "Get my child quality education"
Related Jobs
Jobs that cluster around the core
- "Stay informed about my child's progress"
- "Connect with other parents"
- "Feel confident in school choice"
Emotional Jobs
How they want to feel
- "Feel like an involved parent"
- "Feel my investment is worthwhile"
- "Feel my child is special"
Social Jobs
How they want to be perceived
- "Be seen as caring about education"
- "Be seen as making smart choices"
- "Be seen as a good parent"
Discovering Jobs
Interview Techniques
Timeline Interview: "Walk me through the last time you [action]..." "What happened right before that?" "What were you thinking at that moment?"
Switch Interview: "Tell me about when you started using [product]" "What weren't you happy with before?" "What almost stopped you from switching?"
Contrast Interview: "When does [solution] work great? When does it fall short?" "Compare the best experience to the worst experience"
What to Listen For
- "I need to..." (functional)
- "I want to feel..." (emotional)
- "People will think..." (social)
- "It frustrates me when..." (pain points)
- "I wish I could..." (unmet needs)
Competition Through Job Lens
Traditional competition: same product category JTBD competition: anything that could do the same job
Netflix's real competitors aren't other streaming services:
- Sleep
- Video games
- Social media
- Going out
- Reading
TeddySnaps' real competitors:
- Text messages from staff
- End-of-day verbal updates
- Worrying and imagining
- Calling the daycare
- Other parent apps
Prioritizing Jobs
Importance Matrix
| Well Served | Underserved | |
|---|---|---|
| Important | Maintain | OPPORTUNITY |
| Unimportant | Ignore | Ignore |
Opportunity Score
Importance + (Importance - Satisfaction) = Opportunity
High importance + Low satisfaction = Biggest opportunity
Integration with Other Skills
- First Principles: What's the atomic need behind this job?
- Second-Order: If we solve this job, what happens next?
- Inversion: What would make us terrible at this job?
- Cross-Pollination: Who else solves similar jobs well?